We didn't realize eating marshmallow Peeps was a competitive sport until Matt Stonie broke his own world record by scarfing down 255 Peeps in five minutes.

It sounded like a challenge to AJ and Nikki. The problem was: They didn't have 255 Peeps. They only had three boxes. It would have to do...

So, how many Easter Peeps can AJ devour in 20 seconds? He says he can eat all three boxes. Nikki is skeptical. Let's find out!